Historical objections to the claim that rockets can create thrust in space.
Hello and a Happy New Year five, Cluesforumers! You see in 2018 at the vernal equinox a new age took its beginning when Simon Schack released his Tychos model that demonstrates that the heliocentric model of the Solar system is impossible and that the model he suggests, based on Tycho Brahe's model, agrees with all known observations and experiments.
I've been playing with a new "AI Language Model" called chatgpt
https://chat.openai.com/chat and is pretty amazed about what it can find. So the other day I asked it something that's been bugging me for some time. Since it is so obvious when you look into the actual physics of it, that rockets indeed have no way to produce thrust in space, hasn't there been at least a few people in the past besides that NY-times editorial, that dared to speak up against this folly? Turns out there has been, but I've been unable to find them through regular Internet searches since it seems they are kept away from electronic archives. So even though chatgpt lists some links, I couldn't find all of them. I'd be grateful if someone else give it a try as well. And of course chatgpt itself claims rockets work in space "because an action produces a reaction". Never mind that it's an experimentally verified law of physics that gas expanding freely does not create any action and hence no reaction.
*************
Edit, this gets even better. Upon further inquiry, chatgpt claims Aristotle and even Newton himself objected to the idea of rockets being able to create thrust in space:
Yes, there have been other historical texts that objected to the idea that rockets are able to create thrust in space. One notable example is the "Problem of the Three Journeys" put forward by the ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle.
In his book "On the Heavens," Aristotle argued that since there is no air in space, there can be no motion because motion requires a medium to move through. He therefore rejected the idea that rockets could work in a vacuum, since there is no air for the exhaust gases to push against and create thrust.
In the 17th century, the English scientist Isaac Newton argued that rockets would not work in a vacuum because they rely on the principle of action and reaction, which states that for every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. According to Newton, if a rocket were to eject exhaust gases in a vacuum, there would be no reaction force to push the rocket forward.
I can provide you with a reference to a book where Isaac Newton discussed his ideas about rockets and vacuum:
"Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy" by Isaac Newton. In this book, which was first published in 1687, Newton laid out his laws of motion and explained how they applied to the motion of objects in space. In Book II, Propositions 13-15, Newton discusses the motion of rockets and argues that they would not work in a vacuum because there would be no air to push against.
*******************
Chatgpt conversation:
Do you know of any historical texts that objects to the idea that rockets are able to create thrust in space
Yes, there have been historical texts and scientific debates regarding the idea that rockets can create thrust in space. One of the most famous debates on this topic occurred in the early 20th century between two scientists, Hermann Oberth and Robert Goddard.
Hermann Oberth, a German scientist and one of the pioneers of rocketry, argued that rockets could indeed generate thrust in the vacuum of space, based on his understanding of the laws of physics. However, Robert Goddard, an American rocket engineer, faced criticism from many in the scientific community who believed that rockets would not work in a vacuum.
One of the most famous objections to the idea of rockets creating thrust in space came from the physicist James Clerk Maxwell in the 19th century. Maxwell argued that a rocket could not generate thrust in space because there would be nothing for the exhaust gases to push against. However, his objections were later overcome by the understanding of the conservation of momentum, which explains that a rocket generates thrust by expelling exhaust gases out the back, which creates a reaction force in the opposite direction.
Despite early skepticism, rocketry has been successfully demonstrated to work in space, including during the space race of the mid-20th century, and continues to be used for space exploration and travel today.
Can you give me references
Sure, here are some references related to the historical debates about rockets generating thrust in space:
Hermann Oberth's book "Die Rakete zu den Planetenräumen" (The Rocket into Interplanetary Space) was published in 1923 and provides insight into his arguments in favor of rockets generating thrust in space.
Robert Goddard's article "A Method of Reaching Extreme Altitudes," published in 1919, outlines his early ideas about using rockets for spaceflight and addresses some of the objections raised by critics.
James Clerk Maxwell's book "Theory of Heat" includes his objections to the idea of rockets generating thrust in space. This book was published in 1871.
A paper by the physicist William Leitch, "On the Action of Aeriform Fluids in Propulsion and in Imparting Motion to Solids," published in 1861, also includes some objections to the idea of rockets generating thrust in space.
For a more modern perspective, you can refer to textbooks on rocket propulsion and spaceflight, such as "Rocket Propulsion Elements" by George Sutton and Oscar Biblarz or "Fundamentals of Astrodynamics" by Roger Bate, Donald Mueller, and Jerry White.
Could you give some url references
Sure, here are some URL references related to the historical debates about rockets generating thrust in space:
Hermann Oberth's book "Die Rakete zu den Planetenräumen" is available online in German at
https://archive.org/details/dieraketenz ... 8/mode/2up.
Robert Goddard's article "A Method of Reaching Extreme Altitudes" is available online at
https://history.nasa.gov/monograph4.pdf.
James Clerk Maxwell's book "Theory of Heat" is available online at
https://archive.org/details/theoryofheat00maxwrich
William Leitch's paper "On the Action of Aeriform Fluids in Propulsion and in Imparting Motion to Solids" is available online at
https://archive.org/details/philtrans03 ... 0/mode/2up.
"Rocket Propulsion Elements" by George Sutton and Oscar Biblarz can be found at
https://www.wiley.com/en-us/Rocket+Prop ... 1118753651.
"Fundamentals of Astrodynamics" by Roger Bate, Donald Mueller, and Jerry White can be found at
https://www.amazon.com/Fundamentals-Ast ... 0486600610.